Should I repair or replace my fridge?
Fridges last a long time but fail in expensive ways. Many faults are well worth fixing — but a dead compressor on an older fridge is almost always a replacement. Here's how to tell which side you're on.
Common fridge faults — and what's worth fixing
Honest verdicts based on typical repair costs vs. lifespan. Your specific quote and replacement price still drive the final answer — that's what the calculator does.
| Fault | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Not cooling — thermostat or sensor | Repair | Often a small part swap; very high value vs. a new fridge. |
| Door seal failing | Repair | Cheap part. Also restores energy efficiency. |
| Fan motor noisy or stopped | Repair | Inexpensive fix, well worth it on a fridge under 10 years old. |
| Compressor failure | Usually replace | Compressor + refrigerant work often costs as much as a new mid-range fridge. |
| Refrigerant leak | Usually replace | Sealed-system work is expensive and rarely cost-effective on older units. |
| Ice maker failed | Repair (or live without) | Standalone module — often replaceable cheaply. |
Repair almost any fault on a fridge under 8 years old. Past 10 years, only repair if the fix is small and the unit is otherwise excellent.
That's the heuristic. The calculator does it properly — with your actual quote, live replacement prices, and confidence scoring.
Repair when…
- ·Fridge is under 8 years old
- ·Fault is thermostat, fan, sensor, seal, or ice maker
- ·Repair is under 40% of a comparable new fridge
- ·It runs cold and quiet otherwise
Replace when…
- ·Compressor or sealed system has failed
- ·Fridge is 10+ years old and energy-inefficient
- ·Multiple faults in the last 2 years
- ·Repair quote is above 50% of new
Sealed-system and refrigerant work must be done by a certified technician — never DIY.
Run the numbers on your fridge
We'll combine your repair quote, live replacement prices, lifespan, and reliability into one transparent recommendation — with confidence and next steps.
Open the calculatorFAQ
How long does a fridge last?
Most fridges last 12–15 years; high-end models can last 20.
Is a fridge compressor worth replacing?
Rarely. On a fridge over 8 years old, a compressor replacement usually costs more than a new mid-range fridge.
Does a new fridge save electricity?
Yes — modern A-class fridges can use 30–50% less power than units from 10+ years ago, which compounds across years.